500 free credits, no card. Try Smalt AI →

People

Best way to collect feedback from a new hire after their first 30 days

Send a short, confidential survey around day 30 and pair it with a manager 1:1. Repeat the same questions at 90 days, then tell the hire what changed.

Smalt AI team ·

Use two channels around day 30: a short, confidential survey the hire can answer in under 15 minutes, and a 1:1 with their manager. Ask the same core questions again at 90 days so you can see change. Then share the themes and tell the hire what you changed, because feedback that disappears teaches people to stop giving it.

Running a day-30 and day-90 feedback check-in

1. Pick a fixed checkpoint and keep it

Google’s re:Work guide on onboarding describes surveying new hires at 30, 90 and 365 days, with the same questions each time so the answers can be compared across the first year. You do not need all three on day one. Start with day 30 and put the 90-day date in the hire’s calendar at the same time.

Sending the survey a few days either side of day 30 is my suggestion, not a researched rule. What matters more is that every hire gets it at roughly the same point, so the answers line up.

2. Keep the survey short and mixed

Google’s survey takes under 15 minutes and mixes multiple-choice with open-ended questions. It is voluntary, and people can skip questions. It is organised around three themes: technology and tools, productivity and skills, and culture and connection.

A workable version for a smaller team is eight to twelve questions, grouped the same way, plus the questions you will ask in the manager 1:1 (step 4). The sample questions below are my own wording, not Google’s, and the last column is my reading of what each theme can show.

ThemeSample questionWhat it tells you
Tools and accessDid you have what you needed to work on day one?Whether setup and permissions were ready
Skills and productivityHow clear are your goals for the next 60 days?Whether expectations are understood
Culture and connectionWho do you go to when you are stuck?Whether the hire has found people to ask
Manager 1:1Have you and your manager discussed goals and performance metrics?Whether the manager has set expectations

Finish the survey with one open question: what is one thing we should change for the next person who joins? Use a rating scale for the closed questions and keep the wording identical at 90 days. If you reword them, you lose the comparison.

3. Decide what “confidential” means and say it

Google describes its survey as confidential, and it compares responses by group, such as role type and career level. For a team of a few people, a group of one is easy to identify. Decide before you send whether you will report results only when a group has several respondents, who can see individual answers, and where free-text comments go. Then state that in the invite. Whether to run it as fully anonymous or confidential is your call, and it depends on your headcount and tooling.

As an illustration only: in a 12-person company with one new hire, any result reported “by role” points straight at that person. The founder could instead say in the invite that answers go only to one named person, and that the team sees a short summary of themes with no quotes.

4. Hold the manager 1:1 separately

A survey will not surface everything. SHRM’s Paul Falcone recommends checking in with new employees in 30-day increments and asking for feedback. For the day-30 1:1 he suggests asking what the hire likes about the role and the company, what is unclear, what has surprised them, whether they and their manager have discussed goals and performance metrics, and whether they need more support.

In my judgment, those last two matter most. A hire who has never seen their performance metrics may not mention that in a survey, because they may not know it is missing.

Gallup’s onboarding article makes a related point: managers should meet with new hires and give feedback early and often. It also reports that only 12% of employees strongly agree their organization does a great job onboarding. The page shows no date or methodology for that figure, so treat it as a rough signal, not a benchmark.

5. Compare, then report back

Read the free-text answers first and group them into themes. Compare the day-30 answers with the 90-day answers for the same hire, and across hires in similar roles. Google reports that this kind of comparison led to more than a dozen onboarding changes over two years, though the guide gives no statistics on the effect.

Within two weeks, tell the cohort what you heard and what you will change. If you decide not to change something, say that too, with the reason.

Doing it with an AI coworker

If you use Smalt, you can hand it the drafting and the sorting. Ask it to draft the survey and the manager’s 1:1 question list from your onboarding checklist in Notion, so the questions follow the tools and milestones you actually set. Ask it to write the invite emails for the hire and the manager. Emails wait for your approval, so you can edit or discard them before anything is sent.

After the survey closes, export the responses to a sheet and ask Smalt to summarise the free-text answers into themes, with the comments that sit under each one. You get the groupings to review, and the decisions about what to change stay with you.

What to check before you rely on it

  • Small groups. With one or two hires a quarter, there is nothing to average. Treat the survey as a structured conversation, and do not read a trend into two data points.
  • Honesty at day 30. A new hire may soften answers to avoid seeming difficult, especially if their manager reads the results. The confidentiality rules you set in step 3 affect how candid people are.
  • Theme summaries. Whether a person or an AI groups the comments, read the raw text for anything serious, such as a safety, harassment or legal concern. Those need a named person to act on them, not a theme label.
  • Local rules. Employee survey data is personal data in many jurisdictions. Check retention, access and consent requirements with your HR or legal contact.
  • Closing the loop. If nothing visibly changes, response rates at 90 days can drop. Put the report-back date in the calendar when you send the survey.

Smalt is an AI coworker that takes jobs like this end to end and hands back the finished file.