500 free credits, no card. Try Smalt AI →

People

Write me a rejection email for a candidate who interviewed well but did not get the job

Say no in the first two lines, name one or two job-related strengths, give the deciding factor, offer feedback, and invite them to stay in touch.

Smalt AI team ·

The short answer

Open by thanking the candidate and stating the decision plainly in the first two lines. Then name one or two specific, job-related strengths, give the deciding factor without comparing them to the person you hired, offer feedback or a call, and invite them to stay in touch. Send it once the chosen candidate has accepted, and make it personal rather than a template.

How to write it

SHRM’s guide to turning candidates down (Roy Maurer, May 2025) says to reply as soon as the decision is made and to treat late-stage candidates differently from applicants who never got past a screen. Someone who gave you several hours across interviews should get a personal call or message, not a generic notice. It also advises against contacting runners-up until the chosen candidate has accepted, so the offer is not at risk if your first choice says no.

Build the email in this order:

  1. Thank them for something specific. Mention the interview stage or a topic you discussed, so it is clear the message was written for them.
  2. State the decision in the first lines. “We have decided to offer the role to another candidate” is enough. Do not open with three sentences of cushioning before the news.
  3. Name one or two real strengths. Pick things the panel actually said, tied to the job: how they structured a case exercise, their depth in a particular system, how they handled a hard stakeholder question.
  4. Give the deciding factor, about the role. SHRM suggests summarising what the hiring managers liked and what the selected candidate had that made the difference. Keep it to a skill or experience the role needed (“recent experience running payroll across several countries”), never a comparison of personalities or “fit”.
  5. Offer feedback or a call. Say who they can reply to and what you can share.
  6. Invite them to stay in touch. If you would consider them for other roles, say so, and mention a way to keep in contact such as LinkedIn. Only say it if it is true.

A short example

Subject: Your interview for the Operations Manager role

Hi Priya,

Thank you for the time you gave us over the past three weeks, including the case exercise on the warehouse handover.

We have decided to offer the role to another candidate, and I wanted you to hear it from me directly.

The panel was impressed by how you structured the handover plan and by your clear answers on supplier escalations. The deciding factor was experience managing a team of 20 or more, which this role needs from the first month and which the person we chose has done recently.

If it would help, I am happy to share more detailed feedback by email or in a 15-minute call. We would also like to keep in touch, as we expect to hire in operations again next year, and I will message you on LinkedIn if something suitable comes up.

Thanks again, and best of luck with your search.

Sam

Why bother with the extra detail

The effort is worth it mainly because most candidates get nothing. The 2025 CandE Benchmark, summarised by Survale, drew on more than 66,000 candidate surveys from 110 organisations (data collected 31 January to 31 August 2025). It found that 56% of candidates received no feedback after being rejected during screening or interviewing, and only 6% received feedback on assessments. Candidates who did get specific feedback were 69% more willing to refer others, measured by net promoter score.

Greenhouse’s 2024 candidate experience report points the same way: 79% said they would reapply to a company that gave feedback after an interview without an offer, and 20% had turned down an offer because of a poor interview experience. Greenhouse does not state its methodology on that page and sells recruiting software, so treat those figures as directional rather than precise.

Doing it with an AI coworker

If your team keeps interview notes in Notion or Google Docs, you can ask Smalt to draft the email from them: “Write a rejection to Priya from the panel notes. Lead with the decision, name two strengths from the notes, and offer a call.” The draft lands as an email in Gmail or Outlook that waits for your approval, so you can send it, edit it or discard it.

Smalt works from the notes you point it to. It does not know which strengths the panel actually agreed on, so the specifics are only as good as what you wrote down.

What to check before you rely on it

Reasons must be true and job-related. Acas guidance for applicants in Great Britain says employers do not have to explain a rejection, but that explaining shows openness and helps people improve. It also notes that the Equality Act 2010 protects applicants, so the reasons you give should be consistent, tied to the job, and free of protected characteristics. Check the wording against your interview scorecards, and ask legal or HR if a candidate has raised discrimination.

Whether you must give feedback depends on where you hire. This post does not claim a legal duty to give feedback, and the rules differ by jurisdiction. Check yours, and ask your legal team before writing a policy.

Do not promise what you cannot deliver. “We will keep your details on file” or “we will be in touch” only helps if someone does it. If your data retention policy deletes candidate records after six months, say so or leave the line out.

Feedback offers need an owner. Some candidates will reply asking for the detail. Decide beforehand who answers and what they can share, ideally drawn from the same scorecards used in the decision, so a candidate does not hear a different reason on the phone than in the email.

Match the channel to the stage. A final-round candidate may deserve a phone call before the email. The email then confirms what you already told them.

Smalt is an AI coworker that takes jobs like this end to end and hands back the finished file.