500 free credits, no card. Try Smalt AI →

People

What questions should I ask when checking a candidate's references

Ask every referee the same open, job-related questions about duties, strengths, growth areas, why the person left and whether they'd rehire, then take notes.

Smalt AI team ·

Ask each referee the same short set of open-ended, job-related questions: what the candidate did and how the role worked, what they did best, where they need to grow, why they left, and whether the referee would rehire them. Finish by asking what you should know to help this person succeed. Skip yes/no questions and anything unrelated to the job.

Set up the call before you dial

Start with structure, because structure is what makes a reference check useful. The US Office of Personnel Management’s guidance on reference checking says questions should come from a job analysis tied to the competencies the role needs, that every candidate should get the same questions with a standard rating, and that structured checks have better validity than loose chats. OPM also notes that references predict supervisory ratings, training success, promotion potential and turnover. They do better than years of education or experience, and worse than cognitive ability tests. So treat a reference check as one input to a decision, not the deciding one.

A few practical points from the same page:

  • Run checks late in the process, on finalists only.
  • Prefer the phone to written requests, which tend to get low response rates.
  • Plan for at least three contacts, and about 20 minutes per structured call.

Confirm the candidate has agreed to the check before you contact anyone. Yale University’s HR manager toolkit lists verifying employment details and confirming consent as the first steps.

On who to call, an older SHRM article (published December 2015, so read it as long-standing practice rather than current research) suggests starting with former supervisors, then moving to close colleagues from the last five to seven years.

Questions to ask, in order

Open by describing the role you’re hiring for. Yale’s toolkit recommends this, since a referee can only speak to fit if they know what the new job involves. Then work through the questions below. Tailor the wording to the job, but keep the same format for every candidate, as SHRM advises.

Confirm the role they held

  • How long did they work with you, and what was your working relationship?
  • What were their main duties, and how big was the team?
  • Who did they report to, and how quickly did the work move?
  • Did the role change while they held it?
  • Which of their duties took the most judgment?

Test the competencies you care about

Ask for examples, not opinions. Yale suggests prompts such as “tell me about a difficult decision they made” or “how did they manage a problem employee,” which only fit if the job involves those things. Swap in whatever your job analysis says matters.

  • Describe a time they handled a hard situation. What did they do, and what happened?
  • How would you describe their communication style? Their management style, if they led people?
  • How well did they work with teammates?

Ask about strengths and growth areas

SHRM’s list includes a person’s best quality and the one skill they could improve. Yale asks about strengths, contributions and development areas. Both are open questions, and the second is where referees often say the most useful thing.

  • What is their best quality?
  • What is one skill they should work on?
  • What motivated them?

Close with the exit and the rehire question

  • Why did they leave?
  • Would you rehire them? If not, why not?
  • What should we know to help this person succeed here?

Yale’s toolkit adds attendance against the role’s requirements, which is fine when attendance was a stated requirement. It also says not to ask about sick-time use.

Doing it with an AI coworker

Smalt can take the preparation off your plate. Give it the job description and ask for a question sheet in Google Docs or Sheets, with the same questions for every referee and a column for notes and a rating. Ask it to draft the emails to your referees requesting a 20-minute call, and the Google Calendar invites for the slots they accept. The drafted emails and invites wait for your approval before anything is sent, so you can edit or discard them. The calls and the judgment stay with you.

What to check before you rely on it

Keep every question tied to the job. SHRM notes the same anti-discrimination rules apply as in interviews, and Yale tells managers to avoid non-job-related personal information. Rules differ by jurisdiction, and this is not legal advice, so check with your HR or legal team on what you can ask and what you must disclose.

Do not read silence as a warning. SHRM says that if a former employer’s policy limits what it will say, you shouldn’t hold that against the candidate. Many employers confirm only dates and title, and when that happens, ask the candidate for another referee.

One referee is a single view. A supervisor may have seen a different side of the candidate than a peer, which is why OPM plans for several contacts. Compare answers against the same standard rating rather than against your impression of how warm each call felt.

Record what you hear while you hear it. Yale keeps its reference notes for three years, but that is Yale’s policy. Your retention period depends on your jurisdiction and your own records policy, so find it out before you start taking notes.

Smalt is an AI coworker that takes jobs like this end to end and hands back the finished file.