500 free credits, no card. Try Smalt AI →

Marketing

How do I find the editors at ten publications and pitch each one by email

Find each editor on the masthead, bylines or pitch page, then send one short, outlet-specific email at a time. Here is the method and what to check first.

Smalt AI team ·

For each publication, identify the editor who covers your topic, find a direct address or the section’s public pitch address, and send a short plain-text pitch written for that outlet alone. Here, “editor” includes section editors and reporters who take pitches. Most journalists discard pitches outside their beat, so the research per outlet matters more than the email’s polish.

Find the right editor at each publication

Start with the section, not the publication. Penn’s Annenberg School media guide (undated, and written for academics, but the mechanics are general) tells you to identify the section editor and find their direct email. The reason to be this specific is in the Muck Rack data below: a pitch outside someone’s beat is the first thing to go.

For each of your ten outlets, check these places in turn:

  • The masthead or “about” page, which usually lists editors by section.
  • Recent bylines in the section you want to appear in, to see who actually writes or edits that kind of story.
  • A “contribute”, “write for us” or pitch-guidelines page, if one exists.

Record what you find in a sheet with one row per outlet. This layout is our suggestion, and the row is an invented example:

PublicationEditorAddress sourceAngleSent dateFollow-up
Example Trade Weekly (EXAMPLE)Jordan Lee, news editorMasthead pageGuest piece on warehouse safety2026-11-09Treat as a no on 2026-11-11

Penn’s guide says to check whether the outlet wants pitches or finished pieces before you write anything, so note that too.

If you find a name but no address, Penn suggests asking the communications office. If the outlet publishes a section address, Penn calls using it “a totally viable way to go”. We found no reliable source on guessing address formats or on paid contact databases, so we can’t say either works. Use addresses an outlet or editor has published, and mark any you could not confirm.

Write a pitch that fits the outlet

Keep it short and keep it specific. Penn’s guide recommends one to three short paragraphs in plain language, with a subject line in the form “Pitch: [very short title summary]”. If you are sending a finished piece, paste it into the body instead of attaching it.

The Muck Rack State of Journalism 2026 survey, fielded from 30 January to 2 March 2026 and reported by O’Dwyer’s, gives the reasons:

  • 86% of journalists say at least some of their stories start with a pitch.
  • 88% immediately disregard pitches outside their beat.
  • The top reasons to dismiss a pitch are a promotional tone (71%), a mass-email feel (50%), repeated sends without a reply (46%) and an unclear or overlong message (40%).
  • Most prefer 200 words or less, 62% prefer one-to-one email, and 78% want pitches before noon.

Treat these as what journalists say they prefer, not as a measure of what gets a reply. We found no published reply-rate figure, so we won’t give one.

In practice, the first sentence names something the editor’s section recently covered, and the next says what you are offering. Here is our own template, not a sourced example:

Subject: Pitch: [very short title summary]

Hi [Name], your recent piece on [specific article topic] made me think of this. I’d like to offer a [length] article on [angle], including [one concrete element, such as original data]. I can paste the full draft below or send a short outline first, whichever suits you. Thanks for considering it.

[Your name, role, contact details]

Change the angle for each outlet, and cut any line that would read the same in all ten emails.

Send to competing outlets one at a time, and treat 48 hours of silence as a no

Penn advises pitching one outlet at a time, especially when outlets compete. Our reading: rank your ten outlets by fit, and sequence only direct competitors, best fit first. Non-competing outlets can go in parallel, each with a different angle. Penn does not say this explicitly.

Penn’s rule of thumb is to assume no after 48 hours without a reply. We suggest at most one short follow-up, and only if you have something new to add, because 46% of journalists in the Muck Rack data cite repeated sends without a reply as a reason to dismiss a pitch. Where you can, send before noon, which 78% say they prefer.

Doing it with an AI coworker

You can hand the research half of this to Smalt. A request such as “Find the editors at these ten publications and draft a pitch to each” is an existing brief for the marketing team. For that job, Smalt can research each outlet on the web, search recent news to see what each section has covered, look up the editors, and write the drafts in Gmail or Outlook.

Email drafts wait for your approval, and you choose to send, edit or discard each one. Nothing goes out until you do.

Give Smalt the ten outlet names, your angle and the target section, and ask it to keep the source of every address. Some rows may come back with a name and no email; fill those in yourself using the steps above.

What to check before you rely on it

Verify every address and every name against the outlet’s own site before you send. A person who changed roles, or an address from a third-party listing, will bounce or reach the wrong person. Penn’s advice to ask a communications office exists for the case where all you have is a name.

Read each draft as the editor would. If it could go to any of the ten, it is the mass email that half of journalists in the survey say they dismiss.

Check the legal side if you send commercially. The FTC’s CAN-SPAM compliance guide says the From, To and Reply-To information must identify the sender accurately, the subject line must accurately reflect the content, and a message needs a valid postal address and a clear opt-out that is honored within 10 business days. It makes no exception for business-to-business email, and penalties run up to $53,088 per violating email. That figure is adjusted periodically, so check the live FTC guide for the current amount. Whether a given pitch counts as commercial depends on its primary purpose, so have your legal team confirm how the rules apply to yours.

Last, a pitch is a request. Some outlets take only finished pieces and some may not take outside pitches at all.

Smalt is an AI coworker that takes jobs like this end to end and hands back the finished file.